That’s fine we can use words how we like and, with that character in Alice in Wonderland, can pay them extra on Thursdays but we must then be careful about importing back into our reading of scripture the new meanings which we have assigned to technical terms which, in the first century, simply didn’t carry those meanings. The most striking example of this is the referent of the word ‘justification’: as Alister McGrath points out in his history of the doctrine, what the great tradition from Augustine onwards was referring to with that word is significantly different from what Paul was referring to when he used the word. The problem is that there are a great many things which have become central topics of discussion in later Christian thought, sometimes from as early as the late second century, about which the New Testament says very little but it is assumed that, since the topic appears important, the Bible must have a view of it, and that this view can contribute straightforwardly to the discussions that later thinkers, up to the present day, have wanted to have. Now of course that was a slightly polemical stance, but I still think it was justified. He wrote me a sharp little letter, saying, in effect, ‘You’ve been teaching this young woman theology for a whole year and she doesn’t know what the soul is.’ My reply was straightforward: we had spent that first year studying the Old and New Testaments, and the question of the ‘soul’ simply hadn’t arisen. She replied that she didn’t know what the Christian view was. After a week or two he asked her to compare the Buddhist view of the soul with the Christian view. When I was teaching in Oxford twenty years ago, I had a student who wanted to study Buddhism so I sent her to Professor Gombrich for tutorials. Society of Christian Philosophers: Regional Meeting, Fordham UniversityĪn exegete among philosophers! I don’t know whether that is more like a Daniel among the lions or like a bull in a china shop.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |